|Introducing Maersk Line's new Neapolitan partner|
|Wednesday, 13 August 2014 22:04|
Shpg Watch 6/8/14
74-year-old Neapolitan Gianluigi Aponte represents one of Europe's three major
shipowning dynasties. Maersk is another. Now the two family-dominated container
carriers will be tied together in the 2M alliance.
Let it be said right away, 74-year-old Neapolitan Gianluigi Aponte does not
throw about financial details concerning his family-controlled business empire,
Mediterranean Shipping Company (MSC), and from its headquarters in Geneva,
Switzerland, he can operate and develop its global container carrier and
additional businesses without being closely monitored by shipping analysts and
the public eye.
Even the most knowledgeable and experienced international analysts find
themselves unable to learn how Gianluigi Aponte has actually financed and
structured the company, which has in record-time grown to become the world's
second largest container carrier, and which is currently not that many ships
away from challenging Maersk Line for the top spot.
Gianluigi Aponte's MSC does not - as the only carrier among the biggest
companies - publish its results and other financial information about the
company, which Aponte still heads along with his son and vice president, Diego
Aponte, who works out of Antwerp.
However, MSC Scandinavia and MSC Scandinavia Holding, headquartered in
Copenhagen, do publish numbers for the activities from Northern Europe down to
the Black Sea.
If everything goes according to plan, these two - but very different - giants
of international container shipping, each of them with a global market share of
around 15 percent, will launch a collaboration in early 2015 on the major
routes between Europe and the Far East. The two carriers have named the collaboration
2M, and the venture is expected to have a combined market share of 35 percent
on container shipping between the two continents.
The 2M alliance is Maersk Line and Gianluigi Aponte's response to the Chinese
authorities' decision earlier this year to reject the long-planned
collaboration, the so-called P3 alliance, which included French CMA CGM as its
Ship master-trained Gianluigi Aponte and his wife Rafaela borrowed around USD
5,000 back in 1970, and Aponte bought his first and 15-year-old freight ship,
at 1,750 gross tons, from a German seller. The following year he acquired a
slightly older, slightly bigger ship. Both of these conventional ships were
registered with Mediterranean Shipping Company as their owner and deployed in
regular service between the Mediterranean and Somalia.
Though 44 years have gone by since then, the Italian shipowner - now a Swiss
citizen - seems to have maintained his philosophy of buying second-hand
vessels. MSC's fleet consists mainly of second-hand ships at moderate prices, with the
basic aim of providing lower rates than the competition. 24 years went by
before MSC in 1994 acquired its first newbuilding.
This philosophy has made analyst circles nickname MSC "the low-cost carrier,"
where concepts such as service and other matters, including on-time arrivals
departures, have been considered secondary competition parameters in Gianluigi
Aponte's business philosophy, which states that container transport is actually
a fairly basic mass product that just needs to be sold at a decent price.
MSC has historically occupied the bottom ranks on the international analyses
that are continuously performed on carriers' schedule reliability, and where
company's new partner, Maersk Line, has for years been ranked as the most
reliable of all carriers.
The latest survey from analyst agency SeaIntel , which continuously tracks the
carriers' schedule reliability, places Maersk Line and MSC at opposite ends on
the scale, at the top and bottom, respectively. And according to observers, the
two carriers' historically and widely different business philosophies could
become a challenge for their newly planned collaboration.
In June 2014 MSC's average schedule reliability was down to 71.5 percent, only
marginally better than last-place finisher NYK. At the other end of the scale,
Maersk Line continued its tradition of landing first on the Top 20 with a
schedule reliability of 87.2 percent, though the carrier still has some way to
go to reach its former reliability levels.
"While Maersk Line has always put an honor in delivering a product on time, MSC
has been known far and wide for doing the exact opposite, and the carrier has
pretty much always placed last in terms of on-time arrivals. And I'm even being
very diplomatic here," says Lars Jensen, CEO and partner, Seaintel:
"Arriving and sailing on time has never been a high priority for MSC. On the
other hand, it's fair to say that a very big percentage of customers in the
market do not place a high price on this and are unwilling to pay for it. For
MSC it has for decades been a matter of fundamentally offering a very basic
product at a fair price. Then the product will sell itself. "
But the rapid growth of Gianluigi Aponte's container carrier, and especially
the way it has happened, has engendered respect.
"MSC has grown organically and never through acquisitions, unlike the other big
carriers. At the same time - at least in the early stages, before it went
- the carrier was famous or infamous, depending on who you ask, for the way it
would enter a market. Once MSC had decided to enter a new market, the carrier
would deploy the necessary number of ships and set the rates until the ships
were full and the carrier had secured the desired market share."
"Most other carriers quickly learned that if you wanted to do battle with MSC,
the carrier would just reduce the rates even further, so one might as well let
them enter the market. Once this had been done, MSC would once again increase
the rates to a level more suited for the market, and everyone would be
says Lars Jensen, who describes it as "still an interesting question where the
financing for this strategy comes from." Not least in light of the fact that
money has been gushing out of the container carriers in recent years and will
likely continue to do so for some time.
Whether it was the result of several years of crisis in the container industry
remains unknown, but in 2013 Aponte decided to realize some of the assets in
his container terminals, as he sold a 35 percent stake in Terminal Investment
Limited to investment company Global Infrastructure Partners (GIP) along with a
group of investors.
The two companies described the new partnership as a strategic business, but
Aponte and MSC were also able to realize a significant billion-dollar figure,
which analysts deemed an important cash reserve for MSC under the extremely
difficult conditions for the major container carriers on Asia-Europe. The sale
allegedly raised around USD 1.9 billion for MSC.
MSC's management is said by observers to be extremely aristocratically
governed, with all significant decisions being made by Gianluigi Aponte himself, for
instance at Saturday meetings with his closest employees at the company's
"As far as I know, no decision-making powers have been delegated to the
individual countries," says Lars Jensen.
The other part of Gianluigi Aponte's business empire, for which he has since
1970 received several awards, is cruise carrier MSC Cruises, established in
1989 and currently considered one of the largest cruise companies in the world.
American business magazine Forbes, especially renowned for its annual ranking
of the richest people in the world - Forbes 500 - has estimated Gianluigi Aponte's
net fortune to be around USD 6.3 billion. He has received several premier
accolades and awards in his native Italy.
Last year he received the Al Merito del Lavoro or Order of Merit for Labour at
the Italian presidential palace. And back in 2009, then-prime minister Silvio
Berlusconi honored him with the Neapolitan Excellence in the World award.
The Aponte and Maersk families - along with the French Saade family, which
controls the world's 3rd largest container carrier, CMA CGM - represent the
three European shipowning dynasties.